SAIMC


SAIMC: From the President's desk

November 2017 SAIMC

‘Education-to-employment’ a conundrum in South Africa

Over the years, while at the desk of the SAIMC leadership, some observations, beliefs and perceptions surfaced. These however, must be tested with quantitative data as they are mostly qualitative and gathered over a span of time.

The question that has shaped our observation is one that lingers in the mind of every leader at the SAIMC: “How do we prepare the youth of South Africa, with and without college degrees, for jobs with meaningful career paths?”

Business and societal needs have never been this apparent. South African employers always highlight shortage of skills in the market as a key challenge and often put emphasis on lack of preparedness, even for entry level jobs. On the other hand, this ‘skills gap’ represents a massive pool of untapped talent which can be unlocked through numerous avenues such as bursary programmes and apprenticeships, which in turn addresses the need for experience and formal qualifications. The under-utilisation of this talent pool has dire consequences, such as social unrest and despair, economic underperformance, increasing levels of crime etc.

Workforce development system

After two years of engagement with the private and public sectors, coupled with experience gained in societal projects, we propose the workforce development model indicated in Figure 1 in order to remedy some of the challenges experienced today.

Figure 1. Workforce development model in South Africa.
Figure 1. Workforce development model in South Africa.

1. Employers, South African youth, society and education providers live in parallel worlds

South African employers believe that graduates are not adequately prepared and do not have the necessary skills to enter the labour market, even for first entry level jobs. The educational institutions, on the other hand, believe that the current curricula equip graduates with necessary skills required for the work environment.

The second disconnect is that educational institutions are of the view that the high student dropout rate is as a result of the course content being too difficult, while the youth express affordability as the reason behind it.

The third perspective, that of society, is that the basic education system is flawed and does not prepare our youth for higher education. In relation to the workforce development system (Figure 1), we have four major stakeholders with almost opposing perspectives. This suggests lack of integration, disconnect and necessary communication channels among stakeholders.

2. The education-to-employment system is heterogeneous and fragmented

In summary, the following are our observations:

• High costs barrier for higher learning enrolment and hence disconnect to employment.

• On-the-job training and hands-on learning appear to be more effective methods, but fewer youth are enrolled in curricula that prioritise these techniques.

• Economy and educational disconnect: first jobs afforded to youth are unrelated to their field of study and they want to change positions quickly. The question that surfaces is: what skill does the economy of today demand?

• Disengaged youth: over the years we observed troubled youth segments. These range from those who have become discouraged (“I know enough not to care”) to those who are disengaged (“I don’t care to know more”) and those who are willing yet struggling (“I want to know more”).

Although limited, we share some thoughts on what we believe could nudge us forward a notch.

Lessons from abroad

Two features stand out among leading global economies. Firstly, educational institutions and employers actively step into one another’s worlds. Employers are actively integrated into curriculum designs, and offer their employees as faculty leaders. For example, educational institutions collaborate with potential employers by having students spend some time on the job, and thus secure best student hiring guarantees. In return, employers are incentivised by state government for such participation and programmes.

Secondly, in the best programmes, employers and educational institutions work with their students from the beginning, and intensely. Instead of the traditional recruitment methods (i.e. poaching and competition) adopted in South Africa, the education-to-employment journey is treated as a continuum in which employers commit to hiring youth before they are enrolled in any skills-building programme.

Establishment of industry-specific structures

The most transformative solutions are those that involve multiple providers and employers working within a particular industry or function. These collaborations resolve the skill gap at a sector level. By splitting costs among multiple stakeholders (educators, employers and trainees), investment is reduced for all parties as an incentive for increased participation. Agreements such as non-poaching deals can also boost employers’ willingness to collaborate, even in a competitive environment.

Finally, we believe South Africa is in need of system integrators, responsible for taking a high-level view of the entire heterogeneous and fragmented education-to-employment system. The role of the system integrator is to work with education institutions and employers to develop skill solution sets, gather data, and identify and disseminate positive industry practices and examples. Such companies could be defined by sector, region, or target population.

Yours in automation,

Oratile Sematle



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

SAIMC User Advisory Council KS4I event
SAIMC Supplier Advisory Council SAIMC
The SAIMC User Advisory Council started 2025 with its first event in the ‘Knowlege Sharing 4 Industry’ event series on the 19th of March.

Read more...
Knowledge Sharing 4 Industry
SAIMC Supplier Advisory Council SAIMC
In proud partnership with Innomotics, SAIMC will be hosting the first Knowledge Sharing 4 Industry event for 2025.

Read more...
SAIMC: From the office of the CEO: Quo vadis South Africa
SAIMC SAIMC
In the nineteen hundreds, South Africa built the country while strict sanctions were in place. Control instrumentation and other computer equipment were given codes to ensure the most powerful equipment ...

Read more...
SAIMC: Johannesburg branch
SAIMC SAIMC
At the SAIMC Johannesburg technical evening held on 12 February, Jozua Joubert from TANDM gave a presentation on wireless condition monitoring.

Read more...
SAIMC: A tribute to two legends
SAIMC SAIMC
Change is never easy, especially when it means saying goodbye to two valued colleagues, John Owen-Ellis and Kevin McElroy.

Read more...
SAIMC: Durban branch
SAIMC SAIMC
The first SAIMC Durban management team meeting was held in early February, with secretary John Owen-Ellis leading the meeting for the last time before he retires.

Read more...
How to claim CPD points
SAIMC Supplier Advisory Council SAIMC
SAIMC makes it possible for you to claim CPD points for attending courses and technical meetings, or completing an online quiz on a SA Instrumentation & Control magazine.

Read more...
SAIMC: From the office of the CEO
SAIMC SAIMC
Visiting Mossel Bay in December was an absolute delight. The weather was fantastic, and we had family visiting, which made the experience even more enjoyable. We spent our days challenging the sand ...

Read more...
SAIMC: Johannesburg branch
SAIMC SAIMC
The annual general meeting for the Johannesburg Branch of the SAIMC took place on 15 January 2025.

Read more...
How to claim CPD points
SAIMC Supplier Advisory Council SAIMC
SAIMC makes it possible for you to claim CPD points for attending courses and technical meetings, or completing an online quiz on a SA Instrumentation & Control magazine.

Read more...