News


From the editor's desk: Never again

June 2024 News


Kim Roberts, Editor

The recent building collapse in George shook me as it was just down the road. I experienced first hand the impact that it had on people’s lives, and the devastation caused by the loss of loved ones, family breadwinners and bright young artisans ready to take on the world. Now the focus is on trying to understand what happened and why. It’s important not to point fingers and jump to conclusions, but I couldn’t help taking note of an engineer with 50 years of experience in the business who said: “Buildings do not collapse unless there are huge design shortfalls or construction shortcuts.” Practically, this boils down to five things: the foundations are too weak, the building materials aren’t strong enough, workers have made mistakes, the load is too heavy, and the strength hasn’t been tested. One of the early findings was the importance of workers at every level and in every industry being registered with an accredited organisation that can monitor these things. In the case of the Built Environment this is ECSA.

Small things stack up to a tragedy

This made me think about some of the other manmade disasters over time. There’s no need to say anything further about what happened – Bhopal, Three Mile Island, Aberfan, Fukushima, Chernobyl, Piper Alpha, the Challenger Space Shuttle, Coalbrook − and the list goes on.

In all of them there were a sequence of small incidents that went unnoticed, or were not fixed until things spiralled out of control, resulting in catastrophe. Manmade disasters are triggered by an event or error, but are almost always the result of small factors that seem insignificant on their own, but when combined have terrible results. They may be small, but the list is long: negligence, inadequate training, communication failures, poor maintenance, a weak safety culture, design flaws, environmental erosion, economic pressures, or inadequate risk assessment. Here are some examples.

The fire in Grenfell Tower in London in 2017 started when a broken refrigerator caught fire. The building had recently been renovated with the addition of external cladding, and the polyethylene material in the cladding was the cause of the fire’s spread. Compounding this was the enforcement of a disastrous stay-put policy in the building, and broken smoke extractors.

In 1988, a series of explosions ripped through the Piper Alpha oil platform in the North Sea. Many lessons were drawn from the terrible events, but they boiled down to poor management of a change in design, a pump being restarted before maintenance was complete, inadequate transfer of information during handover of shifts, a lack of emergency evacuation procedures, and a culture of complacency (everything’s fine).

In 1960 Coalbrook became the worst mine disaster ever in South Africa. The disintegration of 900 underground pillars supporting the tunnels caused a massive collapse, and trapped 435 mineworkers 180 metres underground. There were no survivors and no bodies were ever recovered. The accident was caused by cascading pillar failure. Contributing to the collapse was the process of top coaling to get more coal out, which raised the height of the tunnels and pillar, while panel mining reduced the size of the structures holding up the tunnels. A small rockfall two weeks earlier went unreported.

The Chernobyl disaster in 1986 was the result of a combination of operator errors, made much worse by poor decision making during the crisis. During a midnight safety test, operators disabled critical control systems, leading to a reactor meltdown. Their mistakes were compounded by a lack of both adequate training and an understanding of the reactor’s design.

The Challenger Space Shuttle disaster in 1986 is another example of organisational complacency. NASA’s culture prioritised schedules and budget over the safety concerns raised by engineers about the O-rings in cold temperatures. The decision to proceed with the launch was made, despite the known risks.

Overlooking environmental factors can also lead to catastrophe. The Fukushima nuclear disaster in 2011 was a result of the plant’s inadequate preparation for a tsunami, despite being in a tsunami-prone region, coupled with insufficient protective barriers.

The pressure on engineers in today’s process automation plants is huge. They have to cope with containing costs, minimising downtime, maintaining product quality, keeping up with technology, complying with an increasing number of regulatory requirements, meeting tight deadlines in the face of resource constraints, keeping customers happy, and a whole lot more. On top of all that, they have to consider safety − yet another pressure. But by understanding what small things can lead to disaster, they can put into place simple measures that can prevent future catastrophes, and have some peace of mind.


Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Reinstatement opportunity for ECSA registration
News
In 2023 the Engineering Council of South Africa (ECSA) announced a special opportunity for engineers in South Africa to reinstate their registration status if it had been cancelled. This exclusive offer is available until the end of August 2024.

Read more...
100 years of safety leadership
News
DEKRA Industrial and its adult-based education and occupational skills training division, the Institute of Learning (IOL) will showcase a milestone at A-OSH 2025, as the company celebrates DEKRA Global’s 100 years of safety leadership.

Read more...
Drakenstein Municipality aces Schneider Electric’s Sustainability Impact Award
Schneider Electric South Africa News
Drakenstein Municipality in the Western Cape has won a Sustainability Impact Award for Schneider Electric’s Anglophone Africa region, shining the spotlight on its unwavering commitment to sustainable leadership and its forward-thinking approach to ensuring a sustainable future for its coming generations.

Read more...
LH Marthinusen launches new industrial fan manufacturing and services factory
News
LH Marthinusen has launched its new industrial fan manufacturing and services factory in Ekurhuleni. THis is a major milestone for South African energy infrastructure growth.

Read more...
Comtest calibration user group seminar
Comtest News
Comtest invites metrology and calibration professionals to a focused technical seminar series aimed at demystifying some of the most common hurdles in inter-laboratory comparisons.

Read more...
Functional safety explained
News
The SAIMC supports Pepperl+Fuchs, a National Member, in a free four-part online seminar series focused on Functional Safety.

Read more...
The future of manufacturing in Africa
News
The future and development of African manufacturing will be discussed extensively at the upcoming Manufacturing Indaba conference, to be hosted on 15 to 16 July 2025 at Johannesburg’s Sandton Convention Centre.

Read more...
Hot topics at IFAT Africa and analytica Lab Africa 2025
News
Burning issues such as climate-smart infrastructure, sustainability in waste and water management, the circular economy and Extended Producer Responsibility will come under discussion at the three-day conference and forum presented by analytica Lab Africa and IFAT Africa at Gallagher Convention Centre in Midrand, Johannesburg from 8 to 10 July 2025.

Read more...
RS South Africa showcases industrial solutions at MTE Phalaborwa
News
RS South Africa recently showcased its latest industrial and electronic solutions at the Mining and Technical Exhibition in Phalaborwa in Limpopo.

Read more...
Specialised Exhibitions appoints Joshua Low as commercial director for Africa
News
Specialised Exhibitions has appointed Joshua Low as commercial director for Africa. This strategic addition to the leadership team comes as Specialised Exhibitions embarks on an ambitious phase of growth across the African continent.

Read more...









While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd | All Rights Reserved