Temperature Measurement


Eliminating temperature sensor interchangeability errors

December 2000 Temperature Measurement

The transmitter-sensor matching feature of the Rosemount Model 3144, 3244MV field mount and the 644 headmount temperature transmitters can reduce the error in a temperature point measurement by over 75%.

By accepting Callendar-Van Dusen constants, generated from a specific RTD's calibration data, the transmitter creates a custom curve to match the sensor's unique curve, eliminating sensor interchangeability error and significantly reducing the total measurement error.

Most inaccuracies in a temperature point measurement do not come from the transmitter. Although the transmitter will inevitably introduce some uncertainties into the measurement (reference accuracy, ambient temperature effects, and drift over time) these inaccuracies tend to be minor, compared to sensor errors. For most process conditions, the main source of temperature measurement inaccuracy is sensor interchangeability error. For example,

Sensor interchangeability error is a result of differences in the resistance vs temperature behaviour of a 'real' RTD compared to the resistance versus a standard, theoretical temperature curve programmed into every temperature transmitter. Sensor interchangeability error is introduced into the temperature point measurement because transmitters translate the resistance signal from the RTD into a temperature reading using a theoretical RTD curve.

Fortunately, most smart transmitters can be programmed to approximate any 'real' RTD resistance vs temperature curve, reducing sensor interchangeability error in the temperature point measurement. There are multiple ways to accomplish this, varying in accuracy and ease of implementation. These methods include one-point trim, two-point trim - and multipoint approximation.

Although one and two-point trims are simple to perform, they are limited in their ability to reduce error, compensating for only a constant offset and slope change while ignoring errors introduced from differences in the curvature. Multipoint approximations are more successful at error reduction but are impractical and hard to use. To significantly reduce error in the transmitter, 20 data points (40 numbers entered into the transmitter) are commonly needed. Using the multipoint approximation, it would take many data points to effectively eliminate sensor interchangeability error.

Rosemount's system permits total elimination of sensor interchangeability error - only requiring the entry of four numbers. These are called Callendar-Van Dusen constants. The Rosemount Model 3144 and 3244MV temperature transmitters will calculate and use sensor-specific curves, eliminating sensor interchangeability error in the temperature point measurement. This results in the transmitter translating the resistance signal from the RTD into a temperature reading using the true RTD curve.

To illustrate the significance of this accuracy, in a typical North American fuel oil/petrol cutpoint process, each degree of accuracy gained can save thousands of dollars per year. On an average 100 000 BBL/day unit in summer (when petrol is worth $2,10 per BBL more than fuel oil), each 0,6°C of error eliminated is worth $75 000 per year.



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Is the HVAC market in SA missing the big picture?
Iritron Temperature Measurement
The South African HVAC market is currently grappling with a pervasive mindset that prioritises lowest cost over value for money and technical excellence. However, this approach overlooks the significant benefits that come with investing in high-quality HVAC solutions.

Read more...
Temperature monitoring in dairies
ifm - South Africa Temperature Measurement
Milk is a natural product whose processing requires precise temperature settings. The Berchtesgadener Land dairy uses innovative temperature sensors from ifm in key process areas.

Read more...
Measuring temperature, relative humidity and dew point temperature
Senseca Temperature Measurement
Senseca’s range of passive or active transmitters measures temperature, relative humidity, and dew point temperature.

Read more...
Three ways to conduct thermal inspections
Comtest Temperature Measurement
There’s no universal solution for all infrared inspections with a Fluke thermal camera, also known as a thermal imager. You need to match your method to the type of equipment you’re inspecting and the level of detail you require.

Read more...
New temperature relative humidity and barometric pressure transmitter
Senseca Temperature Measurement
ENVIROsense, a new environmental temperature, relative humidity, relative humidity and, optionally, barometric pressure transmitter has been launched by Senseca, a leader in the design and manufacture of monitoring and measurement instrumentation.

Read more...
The role of alarm annunciators in temperature monitoring
Omniflex Remote Monitoring Specialists Temperature Measurement
Director at alarm annunciator specialist, Omniflex explores the importance of alarm annunciators in temperature monitoring applications, drawing on examples from different industrial settings.

Read more...
Increased safety and control in steel plants
Temperature Measurement
AMETEK Land has helped a major metals industry plant designer to enhance safety, control, and efficiency in steel plants.

Read more...
Industrial water heating solutions
Temperature Measurement
Electrolux (Kwikot) Industrial’s massive water heating tanks are making a name for themselves beyond local borders.

Read more...
Optimising steam management for boiler efficiency
Endress+Hauser South Africa Temperature Measurement
Endress+Hauser understands the daily challenges and demands placed on energy and utility managers across the spectrum of steam generation, distribution and consumption activities. Its global team is committed to working with its partners to overcome these complexities, and particularly those that aim for a safe, economic and sustainable sitsce of steam energy production and delivery.

Read more...
Temperature to IO-Link module
ifm - South Africa Temperature Measurement
IO-Link has become established as an intelligent interface for integrating smart sensors and devices in various industries. With the new ifm IO-Link measuring modules, up to four temperature probes can be connected to an IO-Link master port in two-, three- or four-wire configuration.

Read more...