System Integration & Control Systems Design


System integration in the digital age

February 2024 System Integration & Control Systems Design

To meet the challenges of an increasingly competitive marketplace, many manufacturers (end users) must focus on their core competencies, their secret sauce, and outsource the rest to experts. System integration is not a core competency for most end users, and many are outsourcing it. In fact, the trend in outsourcing system integration has been going on for decades, and it is likely to continue. Meanwhile, end users are elevating their internal engineering departments to play a new key role as an orchestrator of a wide and complex ecosystem of suppliers to deliver on the projects needed to support their companies’ strategies.

This takes place at a time when technology has gained a much more prominent and visible role in the success of the overall manufacturer. While digital transformation goes beyond technology, technology remains a key foundational element and true enabler.

Most end users’ projects have seen their solution scope expanded, going beyond the integration of traditional systems and reaching into functions that may have been too hard or expensive to integrate in the past. Many aspects of technology have become easier and more intuitive, in particular around the user experience. Integration, overall, has become more difficult. In addition to an expanded solution scope, system integration faces the challenges associated with brownfield installations with a patchwork of legacy systems.

Specifically these are:

• Many of these legacy systems were not designed to provide the streams of data at the required speeds.

• The proprietary nature of most legacy systems complicates integration. To make matters worse, many manufacturers have ended up with myriad systems from various generations and vendors, often the result of purchases over time. These include machines delivered with their control system, the ability of plants to dictate their preferred suppliers without corporate guidelines to follow, and the diversity brought by mergers and acquisitions.

System integration as a core competency

It’s no surprise that system integration is the core business of system integrators (SIs). They can offer their clients (end users) several advantages:

• Continuous investment into their technical resources. This includes the need to stay current on industry standards for safety and environmental issues. With the speed of technological development and the scarcity of competent resources, this is not a small challenge.

• Development of experience through cross-pollination brought about by ongoing exposure to a wide range of projects across various verticals. This is not easy for end users with only in-house resources as their ‘playground’, as they are limited to what is currently in their own plants.

• Methodological approach to system integration including project definition, project execution and change-order management and documentation.

• Flexibility in projects by following real project demand cycles.

• Ability to identify and mitigate risks.

• Experience to advise and guide end users in the complex digital transformation environment to become strategic partners in decision making.

The impact of digital transformation on SIs

Digital transformation will also transform the system integration business. The value added by SIs is migrating from one of technology deployment to one of deep domain expertise (industry vertical and application within a vertical). This migrates the ‘generalist’ to a ‘specialist’ SI.

The scope of their solutions keeps expanding and no single company, no matter its size, can deliver all that is required. Like IT workers, SIs need to master the skills associated with alliance/partnership management. Increasingly, they will be asked to participate or lead an alliance required to meet their end user clients’ full solution requirements.

The key role of SIs

At a very high level, it is important to recognise the key role played by SIs in the success of end user projects and underlying initiatives. The role of the SI is one of strategic importance, and the development of a long-term partnership needs to be the goal for the end user and the SI. Time invested upfront will help make the right selection. Projects where SIs are involved get funding because they represent an expected positive economic return. Delays in the start of production, and/or cost overruns impact the bottom line. This means their role is very critical.

At a high level, end users need to ask themselves:

• Can I envision a strategic, long-term relationship with this SI?

• Can we partner for mutual, long-term success? This requires an upfront, direct and honest relationship. It is very important to specify the scope of work and rules of engagement at the start and throughout the project. It is also key to have a solid relationship to handle the possible surprises when they occur.

• Does the SI have the required domain expertise (industry vertical or potential application within the vertical)? Is it open to develop the areas not mastered today? Is the SI committed to this industry vertical?

• Will this SI’s experts be able to deliver the assigned projects on their own or as part of an alliance? Do they have the technical proficiency, and can they build it out if needed? Can they lead a group of companies? Can they be a team player with my team and with the external companies?

• Does the SI have the right quality system and a continuous improvement mindset in place to ensure its viability in the long run? Is it CSIA or ISO-9001 certified? Can it be a partner in my digital transformation journey?

• Do we have the right fit and chemistry?

Practical steps to SI selection

Selecting an SI is more than a technical capabilities decision. Diligent preparation increases the odds of a successful project. If you are an end user, the following are practical steps to follow during the integrator selection process.

1. Define the project:

• What are the objectives, scope, resources, schedule and budget?

• What is the motivation behind this project?

• What are the project objectives?

• What do you want this project to look like when it’s finished?

• What are the risks of the project? Are you prepared to manage those risks?

• What is your communication plan?

2. Establish the criteria:

• Does the SI have experience in your industry?

• Does the SI have dedicated engineers with knowledge on the latest technologies, trends and issues?

• Can the SI show proof of project management competencies?

• Is the SI financially stable?

• Does the SI provide post-delivery services and support?

3. Identify the candidates:

• Does the SI have the technical sophistication level to handle the project?

Original content by Control Engineering.




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

The state of the SI industry remains strong and is expanding
System Integration & Control Systems Design
The system integration (SI) industry is expanding with the adoption of AI, automation and data sharing, allowing companies to improve operational efficiency and competitiveness across diverse sectors.

Read more...
The symbiotic relationship between OEMs and SIs
Schneider Electric South Africa Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
While businesses tend to turn directly to original equipment manufacturers OEMs or vendors when embarking on IT projects, the role of the SI as a key facilitator and partner cannot be overstated.

Read more...
Flexible and precise dispensing technology
Beckhoff Automation System Integration & Control Systems Design
The Scheugenpflug ProcessModule axis system forms the basis of Atlas Copco’s dispensing and screwing cells and a flexible integration platform for general contractors and machine builders. Precise process sequences are ensured by TwinCAT CNC and servo drive technology from Beckhoff.

Read more...
The time is now for systems integrators
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
Integrators combine sophistication regarding technology innovation with practical, hands-on experience. Collaborating with systems integrators is the means to significant productivity improvement, powered by the convergence of automation and information and operations technology.

Read more...
System integrators are a diverse market
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
System integrators (SIs) combine expertise on emergent technologies with real world experience. Working with SIs, it’s inevitable that at some point someone will say, “We’re not a typical SI.” And in many ways, it’s true. SIs come in all shapes and sizes.

Read more...
Avoiding the pitfalls of PLC and scada control system integration
Iritron System Integration & Control Systems Design
Upgrading your control system by integrating PLCs with scada systems should be a simple seamless process. Regrettably, the industry is plagued with control system integration and upgrade myths and misconceptions that can lead to liability issues, project delays, cost overruns and decreased plant performance.

Read more...
EtherCAT measurement terminals for vehicle development at Mercedes-Benz
Beckhoff Automation System Integration & Control Systems Design
At the Mercedes Technology Centre plant in Sindelfingen, Germany, car axles are examined with the highest precision on four test benches, in parallel with road tests and simulations. All data is acquired using PC-based control from Beckhoff.

Read more...
Loop signature 23: Tuning Part 2.
Editor's Choice System Integration & Control Systems Design
It is my opinion that most tuning methods are very crude. They do of course also offer a starting point for tuning if one is not fortunate enough to have a sophisticated tuning package like a Protuner around.

Read more...
PIC microcontrollers with integrated FPGA features in TME
System Integration & Control Systems Design
The new PIC16F131xx microcontrollers in TME’s offering from Microchip are ideal for the evolving and miniaturising electronic equipment market, offering efficient power management and predictable response times for controllers.

Read more...
Five smart machine trends you need to know
Adroit Technologies System Integration & Control Systems Design
The last ten years have brought about dramatic advances in technologies that OEMs had never realised would affect their designs or the saleability of their machines, much less impact business models and profits so dramatically. The following discussion will cover key advancements and recommendations all OEMs should be adopting in their design processes to stay current and competitive.

Read more...