Fieldbus & Industrial Networking


Industrial switches: fact and fiction

September 2007 Fieldbus & Industrial Networking

There are many misconceptions about industrial Ethernet switches. Some vendors provide misleading information indicating that their switches have some special features required for Ethernet/IP or ProfiNet. Protocols such as LLDP and IEEE 1588 are 'open' protocols and not proprietary 'clubs' that limit membership. What limits the ability of a switch to support these standards is the capability of the device. Switches require sufficient processor power and memory to support the evolving standards.

Industrial Ethernet switches vs. commercial grade switches

The following are some of the benefits offered by industrial network devices:

* Greater permissible temperature range - typically -10°C to +70°C.

* Ability to handle large fluctuations in power supply.

* Incorporation of redundant power sources.

* DIN rail mounting with industrial equipment.

* Longer MTBF times - typically 215 000 hours+.

* Better shock, vibration, RFI and EMI resistance.

* No moving parts - no fans.

Requirements for industrial applications

These requirements include:

* IGMP (Internet Group Multicast Protocol) snooping for multicast traffic control (Ethernet/IP implicit messaging).

* Port mirroring - to help in diagnostics.

* RMON (remote monitoring) - to help in diagnostics.

* Redundant power sources.

* DIN rail mounting with industrial equipment.

* Metal cases for heat dissipation.

* Redundancy schemes (ring topology preferred).

* Install it, program it and have the ability to monitor the switch and use diagnostics to troubleshoot the network devices.

SNMP features

Managed switches should be a major consideration for industrial networks where the health of the network is mission critical. A managed switch supports SNMP (Simple Network Management Protocol) v1, v2, or v3 and allows communication with network management packages. This requires greater intelligence at the switch, and there is a wide variation in the performance of SNMP in industrial switches. Users should not be misled by companies that label switches that have a web-server or answer to specific SNMP queries as 'smart' or 'managed'. Some vendors state that SNMP is a security risk, implying that, although this is a standard method for all applications, it is a problem for automation applications. For industrial applications comprehensive SNMP support is required.

IGMP snooping

With unicast traffic, the switch learns MAC address by looking into the source address field of every frame. With multicast packets, the switch must deal with a multicast MAC header, which may or not appear in its bridging table. As a result, multicast packets are copied and transmitted ('flooded') to every port of the switch. During multicast floods devices are unable to use the network, preventing control data from being sent. The effect of these floods is particularly serious with full duplex links, because the bandwidth used is proportional to the number of attached nodes - each of which invites a multicast packet.

IGMP snooping prevents packets from 'flooding' a network segment where a node is not interested in receiving the packets. IGMP is an integral part of IP and is used by Layer 3 switches (routers) to report their multicast status to nearby routers. Because a router must look into the MAC header and 'snoop' into the IP header before handling the packet, this capability is called 'IGMP Snooping'. The multicast packet is then directed only to those nodes listed in the router's table of learned multicast addresses said to be interested in receiving the traffic.

This capability is absolutely required for I/O over Ethernet/IP, unless using ProfiNet I/O, which does not use multicasting. IGMP reduces flooding caused by multicasting PLCs. A multicasting PLC can reduce switch performance to the performance level of hubs and severely compromise network bandwidth.

VLAN (virtual local area network)

A VLAN allows switches to create a single logical Collision Domain even though the nodes are on physically separate network segments. The benefit is that instead of physically installing hardware to segment a network, VLANs can achieve the same through software. VLAN configuration can be based on port ID, MAC or IP addresses. The port-based VLAN standard is IEEE 802.1q. Each switch in the VLAN must be able to implement the port-based VLAN policy.

MIB (management information base)

MIBs are databases maintained by the SNMP package that logs the device's condition and the traffic through the device. The IETF (Internet Engineering Task Force) has defined MIBs for Ethernet switches. MIBs are critical to interoperability. The NMS (network management system) talks to devices through SNMP, but pulls information from the switches' MIBs. A common SNMP and MIB structure make it possible to operate different vendors' switches on the same network because the NMS works with a common interface.

Ring redundancy

The use of a ring for redundancy or failure recovery is common among suppliers. Since there is no IEEE or IETF standard, each supplier has a slightly different scheme and thus, proprietary method. For this reason, many customers do not select ring redundancy as it would lock them into a particular supplier. Those customers choose Rapid Spanning Tree - an IEEE standard redundancy scheme that can be used for most applications. Ring redundancy must be configured in managed switches using, according to the vendor, pre-defined ports, and one switch must be defined as the 'ring manager'. Switches should allow any ports to be used as 'ring' ports.

Rapid Spanning Tree Protocol redundancy (RSTP)

This redundancy scheme allows a back-up path to be put in a standby mode and activated upon failure of the primary path. The network topology can be in a ring - similar to ring redundancy. Different switch vendors that support RSTP in their managed switches can be used in the same network segments as RSTP is an IEEE standard. Users must configure RSTP in managed switches - defining various aspects of the configuration.

Setting up managed switches

Most parameters are easily configured:

* Setting the IP address and optionally giving the switch a name, location and description.

* Enabling IGMP snooping.

* Port Control - turning off unused ports.

* Security - entering the IP addresses (of laptops, desktops) allowed for management changes.

* Ring redundancy - entering the ports used for the ring.

Parameters that are more difficult: you should read the manual:

* VLANs.

* RSTP Redundancy - setting all the necessary parameters.

For more information contact Mark Dilchert, Lapp Cable, 0861 CABLES, mark@lappcable.co.za, www.lappcable.co.za



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

EtherCAT interoperability removes industrial networking barriers
Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Selecting the right communication technology is one of the most important decisions engineers make, and interoperability helps with that decision. Key development tools and standards ensure interoperability among many EtherCAT devices and manufacturers.

Read more...
Condition monitoring to go
Turck Banner Southern Africa Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Anyone who wants to efficiently monitor the climate in control cabinets will find a comprehensive range of control cabinet monitors for the DIN rail in Turck Banner’s cabinet condition monitoring family.

Read more...
Cables and wires for food and beverage
LAPP Southern Africa Enclosures, Cabling & Connectors
The strict hygiene regulations for handling foodstuffs stipulate particularly complex requirements for electrical components. The cables and accessories used must withstand a wide range of chemical, thermal and mechanical loads, and also function perfectly at all times in refrigerated and damp rooms.

Read more...
A new standard in high-speed Ethernet communication
Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The TXMC897 module from TEWS Technologies supports a range of Ethernet standards and speeds, making it suitable for diverse applications, including the defence, industrial, and IIoT markets.

Read more...
Data-driven battery production
Turck Banner Southern Africa Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The availability of high-performance batteries at moderate prices is one of the most important factors for the success of electromobility. As a long-standing automation partner to the automotive industry, Turck Banner supports the major battery manufacturers with its know-how.

Read more...
Bring critical temperature data to your condition monitoring system
Turck Banner Southern Africa Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Data conversion just got easier. Turck Banner converters are compact, simple add-ons that seamlessly fit into your factory applications. You can take various types of signals such as discrete, analogue and many others, and convert them to protocols like IO-link, PICK-IQ, PWM/PFM, and Modbus.

Read more...
Case History 190: Measurement problem ruins level control.
Michael Brown Control Engineering Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
The widely held belief in many plants that tuning will solve all base layer control problems is completely fallacious. Bad tuning is generally not the main reason for loops to perform badly. It is important when performing optimisation that all elements in a loop are considered, in addition to the control strategy, before even thinking of tuning.

Read more...
Precise part machining
Beckhoff Automation Editor's Choice Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
toolcraft manufactures on behalf of its customers using its 60 CNC machines, and designs, plans and builds turnkey production systems for companies in various industries, having added injection moulding, mould making and additive manufacturing technologies along the way. Robotics is the company’s newest technology division. This is why toolcraft relies on PC-based control, including in the production cells, which have seven-axis milling robots for machining components at CNC level.

Read more...
Fully digital vertical roller mills
Loesche South Africa Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Vertical roller mills are found in mining and cement milling operations worldwide. They require complex technology for their operation. As a leader in this field, LOESCHE has proven software solutions for digitalisation that can optimise each piece of milling equipment for energy efficiency, and increase its availability and output, making the plant easy to operate.

Read more...
CNC cycle package for triple-axis milling and drilling
Beckhoff Automation Fieldbus & Industrial Networking
Beckhoff provides a comprehensive package of different cycles for triple-axis milling and drilling machines with the TwinCAT 3 CNC milling base.

Read more...